A favicon is worth a thousand keywords

Last week, Google began rolling out some mobile search redesigns — namely, a new black label for ads and favicons for organic search results. The company said that during testing, the favicons made it easier for the majority of users to identify websites and more than two-thirds of users reported that it was easier to scan results more quickly.

Whether that’s an accurate reflection of user sentiment or not, content creators and digital marketers feel as though Google has designed aspects of its business model to ride on the coattails of what’s best for the user while leaving them to do the heavy lifting.

Ads? Favicons? Fadvicons?

Part of the controversy is how subtle the new ads label is, especially compared to past iterations.

While this may be advantageous for advertisers who don’t want to broadcast that they’re paying to appear at the top of search results, it’s frustrating for SEO Companys…

…especially because our content becomes less distinguishable from paid placements and because Google makes money every time someone clicks on an ad — whether they know it’s an ad or not. This combination can potentially mislead users on a large scale, particularly in instances when the URL isn’t visible.

Can the guidelines save us?

Introducing new features can inadvertently introduce new ways to exploit the system as well. To Google’s credit, they generally publish guidelines so webmasters know what’s fair game. The SERP favicon guidelines are as follows:

  • Both the favicon file and the home page must be crawlable by Google.
  • Your favicon should be a visual representation of your website’s brand, to help users quickly identify your site when they scan through search results.
  • Your favicon should be a multiple of 48px square, for example: 48x48px, 96x96px, 144x144px and so on. SVG files, of course, do not have a specific size. Any valid favicon format is supported. Google will rescale your image to 16x16px for use in search results, so make sure that it looks good at that resolution.
  • The favicon URL should be stable (don’t change the URL frequently).
  • Google will not show any favicon that it deems inappropriate, including pornography or hate symbols (for example, swastikas). If this type of imagery is discovered within a favicon, Google will replace it with a default icon.

The second item is the most ambiguous as publishers are the ones that define what their brands are about. Bill Hartzer decided to put this to the test.

And, two days later…

But, how did Google find out?

Search Engine Land’s own Barry Schwartz reported that there doesn’t seem to be a penalty in terms of rankings or placement in search — just the loss of your custom favicon in SERPs.

This has some site owners scrambling to adjust or replace their favicons to meet the guidelines and yearning for more details on how the entire favicon screening process works. And, where there’s a lack of transparency, people will try to make money…or at least, joke about it.

The LOLs

As passionate and poignant as some SEO Companys are about these changes, some are just as keen to share a meme, have a laugh and remind one another that we’re all in it together.

Here’s Itamar Blauer’s take on the new black ads label:

Lily Ray on the restrictive favicon dimensions:

And, Cyrus Shepard, trying to make author photos a thing again.

Gifs and jokes aside, these unilateral decisions have enormous implications for the marketers, publishers, brands and creators whose content Google relies on to attract searchers.

Earlier this month, the announcement of support for How-to markup had many SEO Companys feeling as though Google was appropriating content so that it could keep users on SERPs and serve them more ads. In March, a very belated pagination announcement also made SEO Companys feel like they had been unnecessarily kept in the dark.

As this behavior becomes more prevalent, so too do the discussions about how we can affect the features and policies that Google puts in place, and if not, how we can free ourselves from them.


About The Author

seo company
George Nguyen is an Associate Editor at Third Door Media. His background is in content marketing agency, journalism, and storytelling.

Website Design Greenville SC by DBL07